Please help to Identify 2 silver coins bought at Mumbai chor bazaar

[putracharles]

The little square silver mohur , i suspect it is fake, and what dynasty is this?

The silver ruppee from Khilji dynasty, is it genuine?

Thanks a lot for whatever help and explanation you can give. CHeers!

[Md. Shariful Islam]

Lower coin is from Ala al din Muhammad. Date off flan.

[putracharles]

Thanks man! but i want to know is it fake or not? can you tell? appreciate the help!!

[capnbirdseye]

I would say the square one is fake, it has crude legends that make no sense & what looks to me like a bad attempt to engrave Ahmadabad but I could be wrong  , the Tanka looks fine to me & a common enough coin not to warrant faking although on saying that they will fake anything these days 

[putracharles]

Hey capnbirdseye

Really thank you for your comments.......

the little square one is fishy..i also think so...what's more, the color is a little bit strange also..

Again..Thanks for the input!

[Tariq]

Mint of Ala al-din Muhammad Shah's coin is Qila Deogir, which is a scarce mint, Ref GG D227.

[capnbirdseye]

Mint of Ala al-din Muhammad Shah's coin is Qila Deogir, which is a scarce mint, Ref GG D227.

In that case he did very well & made his purchase worthwhile

[asm]

Please mention the weight and diameter of the coin to make it reasonably sure it is not a fake..........

Amit